Iran ChronicleBefore Cyrus - Part 4: The Iron Age Frontier Mannea, Hasanlu, and the Medes
Mehrdad Jamali firouzabadi
Before Cyrus, western and North-Western Iran contained local kingdoms and substantial settlements shaped by regional rivalries and pressure from Assyria and Urartu. Archaeology and ancient texts reveal this varied landscape, while the history of Anshan, farther south, provides a different starting point for understanding Cyrus’s kingship.
At Hasanlu, south of Lake Urmia in northwestern Iran, archaeologists uncovered two skeletons lying face to face in a bin built of mudbrick and plaster. They appeared to embrace. Page Selinsky’s skeletal analysis identifies one as male and the other as probably male. Their nickname, “the Lovers,” suggests a relationship that their position alone cannot establish. They died during Hasanlu’s destruction, when an invading force burned buildings and inhabitants were killed. Their remains offer an unusually immediate encounter with people caught in a catastrophe. Yet the settlement’s political identity is less easily recovered. The evidence for how its inhabitants lived and died does not automatically reveal which kingdom they belonged to (Selinsky, 2017; Muscarella, 1989).
The previous article followed the Lullubi, Gutians, and Kassites through their relationships with Mesopotamian states. In the Iron Age, similar questions of perspective remain important. Much of the written history of the western highlands comes from neighbouring royal courts. Read alongside excavation, those accounts reveal local centres and competing authorities rather than a simple succession in which Mannea gave way to Media and Media to Persia.
Hasanlu and the Kingdom of Mannea
Burnished grey pottery became prominent across western Iran during the early Iron Age. Scholars have associated its appearance with population movements, including the arrival of Indo-European speakers or groups from the Caucasus. But a pottery tradition does not securely identify its users’ language, ancestry, or political allegiance. Michael Danti’s study of the southern Lake Urmia basin examines cultural changes beginning in the mid-second millennium BCE. He finds no conclusive evidence there for a sudden influx of newcomers, while allowing that gradual change might have involved migration. The distinction matters: questioning a large migration wave does not require denying population movement altogether. It means that pottery must be interpreted alongside settlement patterns, chronology, and other evidence rather than treated as an ethnic label (Muscarella, 2006; Danti, 2013, pp. 323–329).
Hasanlu’s archaeological sequence is divided into numbered periods. The settlement destroyed in the great fire belongs to Period IVB, whose end the excavators placed around 800 BCE. Peter Magee argued for a later date within the eighth century, questioning whether some radiocarbon samples could reliably be associated with the destruction and drawing attention to stylistic comparisons. Danti’s reassessment instead favoured approximately 800 BCE or slightly earlier. The disagreement turns partly on archaeological context: a dated sample can establish the age of the material tested without necessarily dating the event to which it has been assigned (Magee, 2008; Danti, 2013, pp. 67–68).
The identity of the attackers is less secure than the fact of the destruction. Oscar White Muscarella and Danti consider Urartu a likely candidate, but neither offers a decisive identification. Muscarella also states that there is no historical evidence establishing Assyria as responsible. Hasanlu’s destruction should therefore not be presented as a securely identified Urartian or Assyrian conquest (Muscarella, 1989; Danti, 2013, p. xxv). Mannea belongs to the same broad geographical setting, but its history is reconstructed chiefly through texts. Ran Zadok places the kingdom southeast of Lake Urmia, centred broadly around present-day Saqqez. He locates Hasanlu within or close to Mannean territory, while also reporting Mirjo Salvini’s proposed identification of the site with Urartian Meshta, assigned to Parsua rather than Mannea. That identification remains tentative. Hasanlu’s relationship with the kingdom requires argument; it cannot be assumed from geographical proximity alone (Zadok, 2006).
The Assyrian accounts nevertheless establish a Mannean political order with rulers, royal cities, and provincial governors. In Shalmaneser III’s thirtieth regnal year, approximately 829 BCE, the commander Dayyan-Ashur drove the ruler Ualki from his royal city, named Zirta in the account. During the following century, Mannea became entangled in the rivalry between Assyria and Urartu (Luckenbill, 1926, §587; Zadok, 2006). Sargon II’s campaigns show how external pressure intersected with struggles within the kingdom. In the sequence reconstructed from his inscriptions, Mannean governors encouraged by Urartu turned against King Aza, whose death was followed by Assyrian intervention. Sargon installed Aza’s brother Ullusunu, but Ullusunu subsequently aligned himself with Urartu. Sargon attacked and burned Izirtu, described as the Mannean royal city, before forgiving Ullusunu and retaining him on the throne.
These episodes reveal more than a passive frontier. Local rulers and governors pursued competing alliances, while Assyria sought to control succession and punish changes of allegiance. The royal account presents Sargon as the decisive actor, but the events it describes also expose the choices and divisions within Mannea (Luckenbill, 1927, §10; Zadok, 2006). Objects attributed to Ziwiye present a different problem. Its celebrated “treasure” reached scholars through the antiquities trade, without an archaeologically witnessed discovery. Muscarella argues that the objects cannot safely be reconstructed as a single assemblage or the contents of a known royal burial (Muscarella, 2017).
Hasanlu, Mannea, and Ziwiye can therefore illuminate the same regional history without becoming interchangeable evidence. An excavated settlement, a kingdom documented by neighbouring rulers, and objects without secure contexts each answer different questions about the past.
The Medes: Rulers, Alliances, and the Question of Empire
Assyrian records first name the Medes in the ninth century BCE and describe numerous local authorities. During one campaign, Shalmaneser III received gifts from twenty-seven kings of Parsua before proceeding towards Median territory. Parsua and the Medes are separate designations in this account: its twenty-seven rulers should not be recast as twenty-seven Median kings (Luckenbill, 1926, §581). Subsequent Assyrian campaigns imposed tribute, deported populations, and extended provincial government towards Median districts. Local rulers did not respond uniformly. Some resisted Assyrian demands, while others sought Assyrian assistance against their neighbours. These records suggest a changing political landscape in which competition within the highlands intersected with imperial expansion (Dandamayev and Medvedskaya, 2006).
By the late seventh century, Babylonian records provide firmer evidence for coordinated Median military action. The chronicle of Assyria’s fall records the Median capture of Ashur in 614 BCE and an agreement between Nabopolassar of Babylonia and Cyaxares, named Umakishtar in the text. Their forces subsequently captured Nineveh in 612. These events establish leadership capable of major campaigns and cooperation with another ruler, without defining the full territory or administrative organisation under Median control (Grayson, 1975, Chronicle 3). Herodotus presents a more continuous dynastic history. Writing in the fifth century BCE, he names Deioces, Phraortes, Cyaxares, and Astyages as successive Median kings and narrates the development of royal power through their reigns. Of these four, only Cyaxares and Astyages are also named in the cuneiform chronicles discussed here. The earlier stages of Herodotus’s account are consequently harder to connect with contemporary documentation (Herodotus, 1.96–107; Dandamayev and Medvedskaya, 2006).
Archaeology contributes evidence of substantial regional centres. At Nush-i Jan, south of Hamadan, excavators uncovered buildings interpreted as temples, a fort, and a columned hall. Godin Tepe’s Period II complex also included columned halls. These remains demonstrate organised construction and differentiated spaces, but their attribution to the Medes is not equivalent to identifying the boundaries of a Median state. Dandamayev and Medvedskaya report Muscarella’s objection that no examples of Median art or artefacts had been established in the archaeological record, alongside other scholars’ attribution of these sites to the Medes. The issue is not an absence of excavated material, but disagreement over what can securely be identified as specifically Median (“Godin Tepe,” 2001; Dandamayev and Medvedskaya, 2006).
The political reconstruction is similarly contested. Dandamayev and Medvedskaya describe a kingdom whose royal authority passed to Cyrus. Julian Degen and Robert Rollinger challenge the reconstruction of a pre-Achaemenid Median state or empire. The Babylonian texts attest named Median leaders and royal power; whether this evidence supports an extensive territorial kingdom, a looser political formation, or an empire remains disputed (Degen and Rollinger, 2019 [printed 2020]). The Nabonidus Chronicle brings the discussion to Astyages’s defeat. In the passage conventionally assigned to 550/549 BCE, his army rebels and delivers him to Cyrus, king of Anshan. Cyrus then takes wealth from Ecbatana, identified as the royal city, to Anshan. The tablet is damaged: the year, Astyages’s name, and part of the account are restored. Nevertheless, it remains central evidence for the victory and for a royal centre possessing substantial resources (Grayson, 1975, Chronicle 7).
The Sippar Cylinder, another inscription of Nabonidus, associates Cyrus’s rise with Nabonidus’s third year, 553 BCE, and reports his capture of Astyages. Dandamayev and Medvedskaya reconcile the accounts as a conflict lasting from 553 to 550 BCE. That duration is their historical reconstruction from two texts, not a continuous narrative preserved in either document (Dandamayev, 1993; Dandamayev and Medvedskaya, 2006).
Anshan and the Foundations of Cyrus’s Kingship
Anshan shifts the geographical focus far south, to present-day Fars. The identification of the ancient city with Tal-e Malyan rests on inscriptions recovered there, including temple dedications and economic texts naming Anshan or Anzan. These finds provide the geographical foundation for interpreting the title attached to Cyrus in Babylonian sources (Hansman, 1985). “King of Anshan” identifies the regional kingship through which those texts present Cyrus. The Cyrus Cylinder, written after his conquest of Babylon, gives the title a dynastic dimension. Cyrus names his father Cambyses, his grandfather Cyrus, and Teispes, describing each as a great king, king of Anshan. The genealogy is his own royal presentation of ancestry: it records both a claimed succession and the authority he chose to invoke (Cyrus Cylinder, lines 20–22).
Wouter Henkelman interprets this background through acculturation, the interaction and adaptation of cultural traditions between Persians and Elamites, particularly in the Fars–Khuzestan border region. His proposal that Cyrus the Great or his grandfather deliberately adopted an Elamite throne-name and title belongs to that interpretation. It is not a recorded statement of their intentions. The broader argument is more important than reconstructing an individual naming decision. Cyrus’s kingship was expressed through Anshan, while Henkelman places its development within a setting of Persian–Elamite contact. This allows cultural interaction to enter the explanation without assuming either an unchanged Elamite population or the simple arrival of a fully formed Persian people. The chronology of Persian-speaking settlement and the identities individuals claimed remain separate questions (Henkelman, 2003).
Across the region, the evidence reveals different forms of power: Mannean kings and governors negotiating imperial rivalry, Median leaders coordinating major campaigns, and an Anshanite dynasty presenting its authority through royal ancestry. Cyrus entered this landscape as king of Anshan and changed its balance through his victory over Astyages. His rise is better understood through these particular relationships than as the inevitable culmination of a succession from Mannea to Media to Persia.
Sources & Further Reading
- Beaulieu, P.-A., translator. · Cylinder of Nabonidus from Sippar
- Translation reproduced at Livius.org · Cyrus Cylinder
- Dandamayev, M. 1993. · Cyrus iii. Cyrus II the Great. Encyclopaedia Iranica 6/5: 516–521.
- Dandamayev, M., and I. Medvedskaya. 2006 · Media
- Danti, Michael D., with contributions by Megan Cifarelli. 2013 · Hasanlu V: The Late Bronze and Iron I Periods Hasanlu Excavation Reports III; University Museum Monograph 137. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology.
Continue this collection
Before Cyrus — Article 5 of 5