Iran ChronicleBefore the First Villages: Hunter-Gatherer Life in the Zagros
Mohammad Javad Shoaee
Long before farming villages, people in the Zagros hunted wild animals, worked stone, and used caves within a wider landscape of valleys and mountain slopes. Evidence from Yafteh, Ghar-e Boof, and Pebdeh offers glimpses of these lives during the Upper Palaeolithic. But reconstructing everyday experience requires more than finding objects: archaeologists must establish how they were made, used, and buried—and distinguish human activity from the traces left by animals and later disturbance.
Reading the remains of everyday life
At Yafteh Cave, in the Khorramabad Valley of present-day Lorestan, a fragment of animal bone bears cut marks associated with taking a carcass apart. Other bones were burnt or broken. Together with hearths and the composition of the animal remains, these traces led researchers to conclude that people were responsible for much of the larger-animal assemblage excavated in 2005.1Yet not everything in the deposit belonged to a human meal. Small rodents and pikas had accumulated through the pellets of birds of prey. Fish bones presented a harder problem: their presence could reflect human consumption, but other animals might also have brought them into the cave. The researchers left that question unresolved.
These distinctions shape what we can say about prehistoric life. A cave deposit is not an inventory left by its occupants. It is a mixture of events that archaeologists must separate before reconstructing behaviour.
Mountains, valleys, and different environments
The Zagros was not a single, unchanging habitat. At Yafteh, the animal assemblage suggests access to several ecological settings: lowlands suitable for gazelles, uplands inhabited by wild sheep and goats, and patches of wooded or bushy ground. The researchers nevertheless cautioned that their environmental reconstruction required more evidence, particularly botanical material. Farther south, Ghar-e Boof overlooks the Dasht-e Rostam landscape in Fars. Its position near a natural pass offered views across the surrounding plain and access to different resources. Early Upper Palaeolithic layers there include occupations dated approximately 42,000–35,000 years ago, using luminescence dating and calibrated radiocarbon measurements.2Pebdeh Cave provides another southern example. Its principal occupation, dated approximately 42,000–40,000 years ago, lay near the meeting of mountains and lower plains. Environmental analyses suggest relatively moist conditions and woody vegetation during this interval. The contrast with evidence from other settings warns against imagining one uniform Zagros landscape—or assuming that every community faced identical conditions.
Hunting and making use of a carcass
At Yafteh, hunting focused particularly on wild goats, with wild sheep and gazelles also represented. Deer, wild cattle, and hare broaden the picture. These were wild resources, not evidence for the managed herds that would emerge much later.
Animal remains reveal processing as well as prey selection. At Ghar-e Boof, researchers identified percussion damage associated with breaking bones for marrow. Their 2025 study found that sheep- and goat-group animals remained the principal sources of meat and marrow across the Middle and early Upper Palaeolithic sequence.3There were changes within that continuity. Partridges and other fast-moving small animals became more prominent relative to tortoises. The researchers interpret this pattern, together with evidence for more intensive occupation, as likely reflecting increased hunting pressure rather than simply environmental change. That explanation is a model tested against the evidence, not a direct observation of population growth. Nor do bone counts translate neatly into portions eaten. Different animals leave different quantities of identifiable remains; burning, breakage, and preservation further affect what survives. The Ghar-e Boof study explicitly examined these processes before interpreting changes in animal use.
What about gathering?
Plants are harder to place securely in this story. An archaeobotanical investigation at Ghar-e Boof identified large wild pulses belonging to theLathyrusorViciagroups as possible collected foods. The researchers presented that interpretation cautiously, while identifying barley grains as much later intrusions rather than evidence of Palaeolithic cultivation.4The distinction is crucial. Seeds can move through deposits because of burrowing animals and other disturbances. Finding a potentially edible plant therefore does not establish when it arrived, who brought it, or whether people ate it. Gathering belongs within the questions we ask about these communities, but the available evidence does not support a detailed menu, a seasonal gathering calendar, or an estimate of the balance between plant and animal foods.
Tools, skill, and local differences
Stoneworking provides a different route into everyday knowledge. Ghar-e Boof’s early Upper Palaeolithic assemblages emphasise small blades and bladelets—elongated pieces detached from prepared stone cores. Local river gravels supplied much of the chert used in their manufacture. Archaeologists reconstruct production by examining discarded cores and manufacturing debris alongside finished implements. At Ghar-e Boof, remains from different stages of this process show that people worked stone at the site, rather than merely bringing in completed tools.5Pebdeh preserves a different combination of flakes, blades, bladelets, and core-working methods. Such variation matters: the early Upper Palaeolithic Zagros cannot be reduced to one toolkit. Scholars also disagree about how technological differences relate to local development and population movement. Similar objects do not automatically identify the same people, and different objects do not by themselves prove migration.
Shelter without a permanent village
Caves were places within a larger inhabited world. Regional surveys in the southern Zagros have identified open-air locations as well as caves and rock shelters, challenging any picture of people confined to cavern interiors. Even rich cave deposits do not establish permanent residence. At Ghar-e Boof, increasing quantities of finds may reflect more visitors, longer stays, more frequent returns, or some combination of these. The evidence does not isolate a single explanation.
At Pebdeh, researchers favour temporary, specialised use associated with hunting. At Yafteh, a proposed spring or summer occupation remained conditional on further analysis of young animals and bone survival. Neither interpretation justifies inventing a precise annual route. These sites preserve fragments of practical lives: obtaining animals, processing carcasses, making tools, and returning to useful places. They do not reveal every conversation, relationship, or belief. Their value lies in showing how much can be learned from carefully interpreted traces—and why uncertainty is part of that history, not an obstacle to telling it.
Conclusion
The hunter-gatherers of the Zagros left no written accounts, but their tools, food remains, and occupation sites preserve evidence of skilled lives shaped by varied mountain environments. Across the sites examined here, archaeologists have identified animal processing, deliberate stone working, and different patterns of cave use—not one uniform way of life. These communities deserve attention in their own right, not merely as a prelude to farming and cities. Their history emerges throughevidencethat is revealing but incomplete. By distinguishing what survives from what we infer, we can bring aspects of their everyday lives into view without pretending to recover the whole of their world.
Footnotes
https://popups.uliege.be/3041-5527/index.php?id=1881&file=1
Return to referencehttps://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12520-025-02191-w
Return to referencehttps://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12520-025-02191-w
Return to referencehttps://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12520-014-0191-6
Return to referencehttps://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/full/10.1086/694077
Return to reference
Sources & Further Reading
- Mashkour, Marjan, Valentin Radu, Azadeh Mohaseb, and Jamshid Darvish · The Upper Paleolithic Faunal Remains from Yafteh Cave (Central Zagros), 2005 Campaign: A Preliminary Study
- Marcel Otte, Sonia Shidrang, and Damien Flas · L’Aurignacien de la grotte Yafteh et son contexte (fouilles 2005–2008) Directly consulted excavation-based analysis supporting the Yafteh discussion: prey, butchery, preservation, animal contributions, environmental interpretation, and conditional seasonality. pp. 117–126
- Mata-González, Mario, Britt M. Starkovich, Mohsen Zeidi, and Nicholas J. Conard · Prey Choice and Changes in Site Occupation Intensity during the Middle and Upper Paleolithic at Ghar-e Boof (Southern Zagros Mountains, Iran)
- Shoaee, Mohammad Javad · Initial Upper Paleolithic in the Zagros Mountains Frontiers in Earth Science 12, article 1352099. DOI: 10.3389/feart.2024.1352099.
- Bretzke, Knut, and Nicholas J. Conard. 2017 · Not Just a Crossroad: Population Dynamics and Changing Material Culture in Southwestern Asia during the Late Pleistocene.
- Baines, J. A., S. Riehl, N. Conard, et al. 2015 · Upper Palaeolithic Archaeobotany of Ghar-e Boof Cave, Iran: A Case Study in Site Disturbance and Methodology.